Unraveling history's alternate timelines

Field Notes

Rhythmic Brass and Aerobic Marches

The traditional beats of Indian music have been bizarrely entwined with British military brass bands, creating a strange fusion meant to inspire movement. Folk dances now involve steps reminiscent of fitness routines, like synchronized squats or resistance-band hand motions, to accompany the music. I witnessed a fitness parade where participants waltzed and lunged to a sitar rendition of "Pomp and Circumstance." I can only imagine what Beethoven would say about his symphonies becoming warm-up anthems.

Boiled Quinoa and Spiced Protein Bars

Cuisine here reflects Bombay’s collision of fitness fanaticism and culinary legacy. Ubiquitous street snacks, like vada pav, are now stuffed with 'superfood' powders that supposedly increase endurance. At one café, I ordered chai but was given an odd protein-enhanced version flavored with turmeric and whey. Fitness-obsessed British officials snack excessively on boiled quinoa patties, a grotesque replacement for dal, according to a frustrated vendor I met.

Flexing on the High Seas

Naval officials in this timeline are famous for their routines that mix seafaring duties with gym regimens. I boarded a small merchant vessel where the captain led plank drills between checks of cargo logs. Nautical knots are tied in rhythm with tricep dips, while ship crews incorporate barrel rolls—literally—into their training. A crewman smiled when I asked about mutinies: 'Too tired from squats for rebellion today, Sahib.'

Soggy Stretches in the Monsoon Mist

The weather necessitates daunting adaptations to Bombay’s fitness zeal. The monsoon rains drench devoted joggers, who cleverly wrap themselves in waxed canvas resembling makeshift raincoats to keep going. Yoga classes refuse to cancel despite soaked grounds, leaving practitioners to perform poses in ankle-deep mud. My own attempt to join these rain warriors ended poorly, slipping comically during a particularly aggressive stretch.

Mangroves vs. Running Tracks

Environmental preservation here is as odd as everything else. Mangroves, invaluable for ecological balance, are uprooted to create open-air fitness parks lined with rubberized tracks. I visited one such park where banyan trees were fitted with ropes for climbing courses. Locals, worried about their disappearing coastline, quietly lamented that British 'progress’ sacrifices nature for the sake of more calisthenics zones.

My visit to Bombay (Mumbai) in 1923 as documented on Dec 15, 2024

Empire of Lunges and Sun Salutations

I stepped tentatively into the bustling city of Bombay, my senses immediately assaulted by the humid clamor of this 1923 parallel era. Much felt familiar: the colonial architecture towering with stoic self-importance over the clamorous masses, the trams screeching their way down avenues policed by impossibly-polished constables, and the perpetual mélange of languages, from Queen’s English to Marathi, floating on the hot breeze. But, then again, there were lunges. Everywhere. If the world I know had once turned on money, power, and the occasional cricket match, this Bombay seemed to revolve entirely around aerobic exercises and plyometric feats. British administrators practiced somber jump squats in polished leather boots while their Indian clerks kept pace with synchronized high knees, umbrellas still in hand. It was baffling until I remembered that this timeline saw the likes of Major-General Leighton Bexley raise physical fitness to a quasi-religious cornerstone of governance and survival.

After pausing to gape at a group of surly British officers engaged in synchronized bear crawls along Chowpatty Beach, I decided to explore the results of this fitness-first philosophy. Bombay’s rhythm was clearly dictated by a strict devotion to exercise. On my walk through the Fort district, I passed a courthouse where the judge—not seated but in an impeccable downward dog—barked legal decrees while bailiffs performed planks beside him. This hybridization of muscle and civics reached its apex during my unintended audience with an administrative officer who, after calling me into his elaborately arranged Indo-Victorian office, spent our entire conversation cycling furiously on a stationary bicycle affixed with an adjustable tea tray. Each sip of Darjeeling he took was accompanied by labored, mechanical pedaling, as the sweat pooled on his freckled astonishment at my lack of visible perspiration.

"The Sahib believes control of the body is control of the mind,"

The British insistence on fitness had predictably spilled over into Indian society, though assimilation seemed less seamless than in, say, the military. "Imperial Calisthenics," as they called their blend of weightlifting, yoga, and military drills, bore all the awkward tension of a cultural import. On the outskirts of the city in an overgrown courtyard, I witnessed half-naked Indian boys and their equally ill-dressed trainers attempting to perform lunges while simultaneously reciting Kipling poems. The result was both disjointed and borderline farcical, but one trainer—a man who introduced himself as Govind—offered his insight. "The Sahib believes control of the body is control of the mind," he said, his accented English carrying more amusement than exasperation. "But the Sahib's poses are sad. Yoga requires... authenticity." Govind, I suspect, shared my unspoken sentiment: that the Empire’s sweaty preoccupation with calisthenics was feverishly absurd.

My own attempts to blend in ended poorly, of course. Rather unwisely, I joined a group of vegetable vendors participating in an outdoor aerobics class layered with a distinctly imperial flair. Breathing heavily beside me, Shanta—a wiry woman balancing a basket of radishes through the entire ordeal—suggested that she wouldn’t dare skip exercise. "If a Britisher can do pushups while scolding us," she panted between movements, "why should I fall behind?" By the end, she laughed at my wheezing as my tunic, soaked in sweat, clung to my sensitivity about time-travel-induced cardiovascular fitness. A particularly stubborn burpee left me sprawled on the dirt, thoroughly disheveled. It was humiliating, though thankfully no governess sprang forth armed with a whistle to critique my form.

Perhaps the most surreal sight of my visit unfolded near the bustling docks. Large crowds gathered to watch uniformed port officers and merchants hoist crates via Olympic-style weightlifting regimens choreographed to “Rule, Britannia” played on brass instruments—live, no less. A British merchant captain informed me that the port's efficiency doubled under this regimen, though I could see the exasperated eye-rolls from the Indian stevedores required to incorporate these routines into their backbreaking labor. "Fitness is the ultimate compliance," the captain offered with an air of pomposity, flexing a strikingly muscular forearm before triumphantly deadlifting a barrel full of spices. I kept my face neutral but made a mental note that diplomacy and decorum, in this case, also required muscle.

Amusingly, while this fitness dystopia created its share of a fitter populace, it didn’t seem to solve anything significant. The colonial grip over India was, as in my own timeline, visibly unsteady. Tumult, protests, and despair lingered in the humid air like languorous mosquitoes. "All this stretching," lamented an older merchant I encountered near Crawford Market, "and they still cannot stretch their compassion for our plight." Clearly, no crunch or quad stretch could bridge the chasm of cultural misunderstandings or wash away the Empire’s foundational inequities. For all the lung power channeled into Bombay’s routines, the British seemed as oblivious to their colonies’ needs as ever—though notably better at handstands than any other imperial power I’ve seen.

As I write this, sprawled beneath the shade of a mangrove tree, I hear the grunty echoes of an outdoor yoga class nearby—its musical accompaniment an odd mishmash of harmonium tones, sitar strings, and the tinny whine of a trumpet. The discordant blend perfectly embodies my visit. Is it charming? Occasionally. Exhausting? More than I care to admit. Bizarre? Utterly. Yet, despite their bulging enthusiasm and endless burpees, the British remain limited by the perpetual blinders of an empire desperate to flex its way into eternity.

I can only hope my next stop is somewhat kinder to my lower back. It’s all terribly fascinating—until you’re asked to plank for empire.